Dear Blick and WeatherCat penny pinchers,
. . . .
The old battery was installed 4 years and 2 months ago. Its voltage was still good, 3.07.
. . . .
Your point is perfectly valid and there is a genuine issue to discarding good batteries from an environmental point of view. I change my battery every year because I use WeatherCat's maintenance scheduler. However, I have a number of other household items that I've added to my calendar - changing furnace filters for example. I suppose you could have your cake and eat it too. You could check the voltage of your battery every year, but not change it until it drops below a certain level.
Sadly, I'm so pressed for time these days that I desperately need simpler strategies. Fortunately, not everyone is so squeezed.
Cheers, Edouard