I agree with most of your opinions.
OTOH, I don't want anyone bookmarking one of my pages and not seeing a severe weather notice. We had those probably more often than in your area. Right now, a 'warning' of approaching rain might cause an "advisory"!!
OTOH, not many people will even need/use a "Contact" page and even fewer would bookmark it!
Secondly, the "Nothing dangerous is happening" line changes color (different colors for different levels of severity) and takes up only one line, normally. There is no point in having an alert system if it's not seen on all the pages, in my opinion. Things can change rapidly around here, just because there wasn't a warning while watching the mesmerizing time-lapse video doesn't mean there is a tornado warning popping up that you won't see if you leave the site from that page. OTOH, (I've lost count of how many virtual hands we're at...), the warnings may not be updated until another page is visited...
I understand your concern about getting 'blamed' for a bad forecast, but he 'weather department' seems to live through most of those problems. Additionally, I have a
red-lettered warning at the top
and the bottom of every page reminding people to depend
only on a NWS site. That would include
not depending on
any private radio or TV station, no matter how many meteorological diplomas their people may have.
Your safety is not their reason to exist.
Bottom line, I think many people would expect to see some kind of forecast displayed on a "weather" site, not just a link to another one. Finally, it's
my site and I will make it
the way I want! ...assuming I can get the php working... and I don't run out of time or my allowance...
Even with this selfish attitude, however, I really do appreciate others opinions!