Trixology

Weather => Weather Hardware/Measurement => Topic started by: elagache on March 06, 2015, 10:30:30 PM

Title: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: elagache on March 06, 2015, 10:30:30 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to da' "mellar-drama" that stubbornly refuses to go away,  :o

It sure is hard to believe, but after all the changes I did to my weather station setup, I'm still getting very strange sensor errors.  Another episode happened this morning.  Here is the WeatherCat status from this morning:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/WeatherCat%20status%202015-03-06.jpg)

Here is the live data view:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Live%20Data%202015-03-06.jpg)

Finally here is a graph that illustrates the period of the outage:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Cooling%20graph%202015-03-06.jpg)

I had a similar episode 2 days ago.  I hoped it was a signal strength issue and turned on retransmission on my console to boost the signal strength.  Clearly that wasn't the problem.

I'm trying another tack.  One of the very frustrating aspects of these apparent sensor outages is that they always happen early in the morning - quite often shortly after midnight.  Now I would much prefer not to have to stay up every night hoping to catch one of these events to try to troubleshoot it while it is occurring.  If the time of day has something to do with the problem that would suggest perhaps the Weather Envoy is to blame somehow.  It has never been replaced and it has a clock so presumably it is possible it could have some sort of failure related to time of day.  I've replaced the temperature/humidity probe, so that shouldn't be the problem.  I've changed the ISS transmitter board since this started happen.  It seems unlike two different boards would behave in exactly the same way.

I have moved the console next to my computer and plugged the data logger into that.  I'll see if that has any effect.  I double-checked the reception.  95% of the packets from the transmitter are getting received, so it is a reliable connection even if the distance is pushing the transmission range of a Davis station.  The signal strength is 30 on a scale from 20 to 60, so it definitely on the low side.  But even so, strong enough to keep data coming in.

I double-checked the 123 battery.  It is certainly not discharging wildly like before.  However, I did notice something a bit odd.  The battery was replaced on February 20th - 2 weeks ago.  Two days ago I checked the voltage and it was the standard 3.23 Volts of a new battery.  Today it was 3.22 Volts.  What is odd about that is we haven't had any power outages, so that battery should be sitting there completely unused.  Now a hundredth of a volt is pushing the limits of the tester, but still, why would the tester show any change in 2 days?  It isn't enough to mean anything but still unexpected.

I've given up on the crowd on WXforum, so that's resource is gone.  Calling Davis technical support isn't an option until I can collect some evidence using the console alone.  Davis technical support cannot provide any technical support if a third party software package is involved - of course. [rolleyes2]  So I'm really marooned at this point.

So if anybody has a bright idea . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/thinking_idea.gif)  I sure would appreciate it! (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/pray.gif)

Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on March 08, 2015, 12:43:50 AM

Finally here is a graph that illustrates the period of the outage:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Cooling%20graph%202015-03-06.jpg)


Edouard, is that the only chart parameter that drops out?
Title: Outage is real. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 08, 2015, 09:01:17 PM
Howdy Herb and WeatherCat troubleshooters,

Edouard, is that the only chart parameter that drops out?

Unfortunately not.  If you check the data it is a real outage and the temperature data is remains locked at the last received value.  When the outage ends there is a abrupt change in the the temperature reading.  All the graphs related to temperature are effected.  I use that graph for convenience because it locked on a 24 hour day and is at the top of my screen.

On the plus side, I've gone two days with the console and no problems.  Too early to tell but at least no more problems thus far.

Cheers, Edouard

Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 08, 2015, 11:33:37 PM
Speaking as a complete 'noobie', that signal strength value could be a useful number. I doubt that that value is recorded anywhere. It would be really helpful if you could no that value the next time you have the problem. If there is a coating of dew on the house, that might even be enough to cause the signal level to fall even further. Again, I'm not even an owner of this hardware, but I never let ignorance keep me from offering advice! As I understand the equipment, there is a different channel for each of the sensors. I'm not sure if this communications is really two-way or not. When data is transmitted to a receiver, the best methods require an acknowledgement from the receiving equipment. That is more expensive, of course, and Davis (nor any other 'weather station' source) may not use that method; they may just broadcast 'in the blind' every few seconds and expect the majority of the data to be picked up. However, if Davis actually looks for a 'received data' message it may simply lock out that channel to avoid wasting energy. I may be over-thinking and assigning 'professional-level' capabilities to this 'consumer-level' hardware. I am also operating on memory that you have reported seeing "invalid" data from other sensors, also; not just temperature. Since spending other peoples money is a common solution here :P how about buying a 'repeater' box and mount it on the outside wall closest to the main station? <Part #07626 (http://www.davisnet.com/weather/products/weather_product.asp?pnum=07626)> is only $200! Sounds cheap to me, especially using your money!  [biggrin]

Perhaps more useful suggestion, would be to create an AppleScript that could alert you with a sound when this happens. I know I've read that WeatherCat has great AS capabilities, but I have no idea if this kind of monitoring is possible. OTOH, the Developer seems to be very helpful, might be worth a note to ask about this kind of monitoring. :-\

Whatever, the cause, I sure hope you can discover and correct it soon. :o
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on March 09, 2015, 08:01:26 PM
I'm thinking (uhoh) that your best clue might be the consistency in the time of occurrence, as you originally thought. However, interpreting it as a temperature trigger is still open to question. A cold solder joint could be affected by temperature in such a consistent manner. Or, there might be an unrelated high powered harmonic frequency causing interference, such as an illegal ham radio or CB radio being used at the same time. It might even be a telemetry signal or cell tower or experimental radio communications signal being operated covertly only at night. I would keep going, but it's starting to sound like alien invasion conspiracies, so I'll leave it at that. Look around your neighborhood. Any new antennas gone up since this started?
 [cat]
Title: Some info. (Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 09, 2015, 09:30:28 PM
Dear xairbusdriver, Herb, and WeatherCat station troubleshooters,

Speaking as a complete 'noobie', that signal strength value could be a useful number. I doubt that that value is recorded anywhere. It would be really helpful if you could no that value the next time you have the problem.

If the problem starts again, I guess I'll have to try to arrange to get waken up so that I can troubleshoot it live.  However, I'm doubtful it is a real signal strength problem because I had set my console to work as a repeater.  That effectively reduced the distance the signal had to travel by 1/2.  The next morning it still happened.


Perhaps more useful suggestion, would be to create an AppleScript that could alert you with a sound when this happens.

Actually I wrote an AppleScript that can do this already.  You can learn more about it in this thread:

http://athena.trixology.com/index.php?topic=1039.0 (http://athena.trixology.com/index.php?topic=1039.0)

Unfortunately, these AppleScripts are in desperate need of a maintenance release and after that a complete rewrite.  However, I just don't have time for that.

I could rig something to change the sensor error alert to make an audible noise.  Sure hope it doesn't come to that, I have enough trouble sleeping as it is!

I'm thinking (uhoh) that your best clue might be the consistency in the time of occurrence, as you originally thought. However, interpreting it as a temperature trigger is still open to question. A cold solder joint could be affected by temperature in such a consistent manner.

I'm reasonably certain the errors aren't because of the temperature/humidity probe because it is brand new.  I replaced it when I moved the station transmitter under the deck.  The Davis Technical support guys were very clear that the temperature/humidity probe should never have the data cable extended.  Alas, I didn't know that 5 years ago when put the station up.  It worked fine until this past October.  Since I knew that was one feature of my station that was out of Davis specifications, I decided to move the station transmitter so that it was next to my temperature/humidity probe and bought a second probe to guarantee I had a solid data cable with nothing outside of Davis specifications.

Or, there might be an unrelated high powered harmonic frequency causing interference, such as an illegal ham radio or CB radio being used at the same time.
. . . .
Look around your neighborhood. Any new antennas gone up since this started?

It is possible that there is some sort of radio frequency interference.  I haven't noticed any sort of new antennas or stuff like that.  Most of the people around here are working families with kids, so these aren't the sort of folks who are likely to be up in the middle of the night when another workday is coming.  I located another Davis station closer to my station than I was previously aware of.  But it is around 1000 feet away and I've changed the station transmitter IDs several times, so I don't think that's the problem.

I've gone 3 days without a problem using the station console.  It would be really strange, but the Weather Envoy is the only thing I haven't replaced in all the changes I've made.  I'll just have to keep an eye on it.

Thanks for the thoughts though!  [tup]

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: Some info. (Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: Blicj11 on March 09, 2015, 09:51:47 PM
I've gone 3 days without a problem using the station console.

Progress! Glad to hear it.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: WCDev on March 11, 2015, 10:20:51 PM
Good news on the console then? U/S Envoy?
Title: Looks like multple "issuez." (Re: "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 12, 2015, 10:20:48 PM
Howdy Stu and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

Good news on the console then? U/S Envoy?

Well, so far using the console instead of the Envoy has eliminated any sensor errors for the past 6 days.  That makes me already tempted to just by another Envoy and hope that's the problem.  Alas, I went back to the ISS transmitter board and the battery voltage dropped by another hundredth to 3.21 Volts.  That's nothing, except for the fact according to the Davis technical support folks, the battery shouldn't be touched at all when plugged into AC adapter.  So . . . . . .

I suspect Davis has some real "issuez" with the power switching logic on their transmitter boards.  I have the original ISS board from 5 years ago installed in the 6382 enclosure to transmit the instrument data at the moment.  As part of this mess I bought a new ISS transmitter board last fall. I'm going to have Davis take a look at it under warranty.  That board discharged a battery from 3.23 Volts to 3.13 Volts in 18 days, all when plugged into the AC.  Perhaps Davis can figure out what this board is actually doing without costing me anything more than shipping it over to them.

Oh well, this "mellar-drama" sure has staying power . . . . .  [rolleyes2]

Cheers, Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: WCDev on March 12, 2015, 11:10:48 PM
I think I'd give it a few more days before shelling out for another Envoy. I don't suppose Davis could service it?

I'm also surprised the battery is draining when plugged into the mains. Having said that, console batteries also lose their voltage even though plugged into the mains adaptor, so maybe they have some weird power management going on...
Title: Da' plot thickens . . . (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 13, 2015, 10:28:08 PM
Howdy Stu and subscribers to this endless "mellar-drama" . . . .

I think I'd give it a few more days before shelling out for another Envoy. I don't suppose Davis could service it?

I suppose Davis might be able to service it, but it is at least 4 years old so the warranty is long gone.  I just did some quick price checking.  At ProVantage.com the Envoy is $116.06.  Scaled Instruments is a bit more expensive at: $122.00.  If I have to pay a Davis tech to work on this thing am I going to save any money?

I'm also surprised the battery is draining when plugged into the mains. Having said that, console batteries also lose their voltage even though plugged into the mains adaptor, so maybe they have some weird power management going on...

I decided to do some more testing to see if I could get to the bottom of this.  First, I removed the battery out of the ISS transmitter.  The console reported the low battery but the ISS continued to transmit just fine.  I then removed the AC adapter and waited until the station stopped transmitting.  It took about 15 minutes which is a little odd, this is the 5 year old station transmitter which appeared to have a dead super-capacitor.  Clearly that sucker isn't completely dead yet.

Finally the ISS stopped transmitting and the console indicated no data and WeatherCat started to report sensor errors.  I have been told that if the AC adapter was plugged in the ISS board makes absolutely no use of the battery.  So I decided to test this by plugging the AC adapter, but not replacing the battery.  After 25 minutes, the console had still not managed to establish communications with the station.  Getting a little nervous, I put the battery back, almost immediately communications was restored.

Ah Ha!  So it has to be bad AC adapter - right?

That seemed really unlikely, those adapters are simple and tough.  So to test that hypothesis, I left the AC adapter plugged in, but once more removed the battery.  Again the station reported low battery on the ISS transmitter, but the data kept coming.  The station has been running for over 1/2 hour on the AC adapter alone.  That is conclusive evidence that is it sufficient to power the ISS transmitter after all.  Without the AC adapter, it went down in than 15 minutes.  So . . . . . . . .   ???

So to return to Stu's initial hypothesis: they have some weird power management going on...

In the voice of Bugs Bunny: "Mmmmm, it's a possibility!" . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/eek-sign.gif)

I think I'll need to get Davis to take a look at one of their ISS transmitter boards!

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: Da' plot thickens . . . (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: Blicj11 on March 14, 2015, 12:43:37 AM
If I have to pay a Davis tech to work on this thing am I going to save any money?

Ask them how much they would charge to look at it.

It sounds like you are inching closer to the finish line on this.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Randall75 on March 14, 2015, 11:57:19 AM
Hi Edouard
 Is your Davis Cabled or wireless?




cheers
 [cheers1]
Title: This and that. (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 14, 2015, 09:41:30 PM
Dear Blick, Randall, and WeatherCat station troubleshooters,

If I have to pay a Davis tech to work on this thing am I going to save any money?

Ask them how much they would charge to look at it.

Sure I can ask, I have to call them anyway to get a RMA number for the ISS transmitter board.

It sounds like you are inching closer to the finish line on this.

Honestly, I'm not sure.  There is something - really wrong - about any device that manages to use battery power when plugged into a steady source of AC.  We had no power outages during the 18 days when the ISS board managed to consume 0.1 volts out of a 123 battery.

Is your Davis Cabled or wireless?

It is wireless.  If it was cabled I couldn't have the problems I'm struggling with.  It is the station transmitter that is having the power supply switching "abnormalities."

Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on March 14, 2015, 09:47:11 PM
Quote
We had no power outages during the 18 days when the ISS board managed to consume 0.1 volts out of a 123 battery.

Perhaps the electron were just settling in the container. If so, then a warning label might be in order for these batteries I'm pushin'!
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 17, 2015, 09:32:23 PM
Since you guys have been so helpful, I just wanted to pass along <a link (http://www.batteryjunction.com/panasonic-cr123a-1200qty.html)> to those who might be needing lots of those batteries. I think $ 11,520 for 9,600 Panasonic batteries is a pretty good deal! And the shipping is FREE!! [cheer] They may offer a cash & carry discount, also... 8)
Title: THIS? is being saved!?!?? (Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 17, 2015, 10:13:39 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and subscribers to my darned "mellar-drama"

Since you guys have been so helpful, I just wanted to pass along <a link (http://www.batteryjunction.com/panasonic-cr123a-1200qty.html)> to those who might be needing lots of those batteries. I think $ 11,520 for 9,600 Panasonic batteries is a pretty good deal! And the shipping is FREE!! [cheer] They may offer a cash & carry discount, also... 8)

 ;) . . . . In the voice of that lesser known Warner Bros. cartoon character: Blacque Jacque Shellacque (http://looneytunes.wikia.com/wiki/Blacque_Jacque_Shellacque)

THIS!?!?!?!??!??  Is being saved!?!??!??!??!? (http://looneytunes.wikia.com/wiki/Wet_Hare)

If you aren't a connoisseur of classic cartoon animation, here is the relevant snippet on You-Tube:

https://youtu.be/8RDXPbi4gfo?t=2m23s (https://youtu.be/8RDXPbi4gfo?t=2m23s)

Enjoy!!  [biggrin]

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]

Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on March 18, 2015, 12:16:43 AM
Whilst Edouard goes through about that many batteries every year, I would hate to see him cut Herb out of his 2? worth on Duracells. I like the cartoon.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on March 18, 2015, 04:23:17 AM
I like the cartoon, too. Used to watch them all the time, back when I was more mature.  [roll]
Title: More sensor errors this morning (Re: "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 18, 2015, 10:15:35 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Well the gremlins did a number of my station again this morning:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Data%20outage%202015-03-18.jpg)

Once more the outage started a bit after midnight and lasted almost to 3 am.  Here is the Live Data:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20live%20data%202015-03-18.jpg)

The pattern of errors is consistent with what I saw when I allowed the ISS transmitter to run completely out of power and shut down.  So it is possible once more that the station transmitter shut down during the period, but that isn't the only possible explanation.

Since I now have the console in place of the Weather Envoy this would make me more suspicious of some sort of radio frequency interference.  But there remains one fly in the ointment.  The battery continues to discharge.  It is now down to 3.20 Volts and has lost another hundredth in 6 days.

I still haven't called Davis tech support.  I'll try to call tomorrow and get them to take the other ISS transmitter board in to take a look at it.  One of the reasons I had waited is that I thought I should double-check to make absolutely sure that the AC adapter wasn't screwed up somehow.  As I noted on my posting of March 13th, the station will operate for extended periods without any battery or super-capacitor power left - just plugged into the AC adapter.  So I can rule out a power supply problem with the adapter.

So I've got to find the time to call Davis.  At least now it seems reasonably certain the Weather Envoy has nothing to do with it either.  When I get a chance I'll put the station back into the mode where the console retransmits the signal to the Weather Envoy.  That should improve the signal strength.  Alas, I have had sensor errors when I had the console retransmitting, so that isn't sufficient to solve the problem.

So unfortunately, da' "mellar-drama" just keeps on going, going, and going . . . . .  [rolleyes2]

Oh well, Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on March 19, 2015, 04:06:13 AM
Sorry to hear this mate. It's gotta be driving you crazy. Hopefully Davis will have an idea.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on March 19, 2015, 07:10:21 AM
Sorry to hear it, old friend. All I can offer is sympathy, so I hope you're able find them gremlins soon!
Title: ISS board going to Davis. (Re: "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 19, 2015, 11:36:31 PM
Dear Blick, Herb, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Thanks for your sympathy.

I put my configuration back to how I had it.  The console is now back in the nook about 1/2 the distance between the station transmitter and the Weather Envoy.  The console is now retransmitting so that should insure as strong a signal as I can get to the Envoy.

I called Davis this afternoon and got the same story.  If the ISS transmitter is plugged into an AC adapter, it bypasses both the super-capacitor and battery.  Nonetheless, they agreed to take the new board I bought back and take a look at it.  Alas, they won't cover the work under the warranty because moving the board from the ISS enclosure to the 6382 enclosure violates the warranty.  Oh well, at this point I'll swallow that cost.  Anything to get this station working properly once more!!!

Oh well, . . . . Edouard
Title: Interesting discovery via blackout (Re: darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 20, 2015, 11:33:13 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "meller-drama,"

We had a 15 minute power outage last night that was just enough misery to remember the power outage drill and meet a neighbor by the light of flashlights.  However, this did settle a question that the Davis tech support fellow I spoke yesterday afternoon didn't know.  He was under the impression that plugging your station transmitter board into an AC adapter would prevent the transmitter from ever using the battery.  Well if that was true during the time the power was out, there should have been no signal and WeatherCat should have reported sensor errors.  There were no sensor errors or gaps in the real data graphs.  I had to do it da' hard way, but it seems I've learned something that even Davis technical support didn't know.  If you use AC to power your station transmitter, you should still put a 123 battery in the transmitter to avoid losing data during a power outage.

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 21, 2015, 01:19:51 AM
Perhaps he meant that the battery or super cap would never be used as long as AC power was available. :) As most of us learned, "assuming" things is a great way to create confusion! :P

"Cheer up!"

"Oops! :o I thought you said, 'Gear up'!" :-[
Title: Design exceeds tech support knowledge (Re: "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 21, 2015, 08:58:56 PM
Dear xairbusdriver, and subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Perhaps he meant that the battery or super cap would never be used as long as AC power was available. :) As most of us learned, "assuming" things is a great way to create confusion! :P

Actually the Davis tech guy was extremely explicit that he thought having anything plugged into the jack for the AC adapter would cause the battery to be bypassed.  His thinking was there was some sort of mechanical or electrical switch to completely cut of the part of the circuitry that involved either the battery or the super-capacitor.

Now honestly that would be an extremely stupid design.  The Davis engineers had to have considered how to power the ISS transmitter in case of a power outage.  These are research grade instruments so they need to run 24/7 and power outages happen.  So it is clear that the engineers did the right thing.  It is a bit surprising that the Davis technical support guys didn't know how this works.  It is very unusual to use the AC adapter to power an ISS transmitter, but I assume there is an odd case or two.



"Cheer up!"

"Oops! :o I thought you said, 'Gear up'!" :-[

Oh, do you mean "gear up" like this?  [biggrin]

(http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Two-truck%20Heisler.jpg)

Keep that train of thought!!

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 21, 2015, 09:27:29 PM
Quote
It is wireless. If it was cabled I couldn't have the problems I'm struggling with. It is the station transmitter that is having the power supply switching "abnormalities."
I'm a bit (OK, a LOT) confused. What does the AC Adaptor have to do with the wireless board on the ISS? I thought the only adaptor for the wireless model was for the Console (or the data logger, if used). I think there is a jack for the power/communications cable on all the Vantage models, however. Of course, I don't even have physical access to the thing, so consider the source! :-[
Title: Details on station makeover (Re: darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 22, 2015, 10:11:34 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and subscribers to my darn "mellar-drama" . . . .

First things first, guess what happened again this morning:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20graph%202015-03-22.jpg)

The time is slightly different, but the overall effect is every similar.  Here is the overall status:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20status%202015-03-22.jpg)

Here is the Live Data view:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20live%20data%202015-03-22.jpg)

The whole experience leads me to wonder about an EFI interference of some sort.  However, it would most likely be an automated source to be so uniform.  A HAM radio operator would operate at other times besides early morning and isn't like to be disciplined enough to keep all transmissions between an hour and 90 minutes.

Oh well, . . . .

Quote
It is wireless. If it was cabled I couldn't have the problems I'm struggling with. It is the station transmitter that is having the power supply switching "abnormalities."
I'm a bit (OK, a LOT) confused. What does the AC Adaptor have to do with the wireless board on the ISS? I thought the only adaptor for the wireless model was for the Console (or the data logger, if used). I think there is a jack for the power/communications cable on all the Vantage models, however. Of course, I don't even have physical access to the thing, so consider the source! :-[

It turns out that you can power a station transmitter with the standard Davis AC adapter.  I found that out on the WXForum and thought this would surely solve all my problems.  Here is some pictures of my current station setup.  Instead of just having the temperature/humidity probe under the deck, it now looks like this:

(http://canebas.smugmug.com/Nature/Weather/2015-weather-station-makeover/i-2tHQmFf/0/L/humidity%20probe%20-L.jpg) (http://canebas.smugmug.com/Nature/Weather/2015-weather-station-makeover/i-2tHQmFf/A)

The box on the left is a Davis 6382 enclosure that now houses the station transmitter board that came from my original Davis station.  Here is what that box looks like on the inside:

(http://canebas.smugmug.com/Nature/Weather/2015-weather-station-makeover/i-wsL8VNG/0/L/Station%20transmitter%20in%20a%206382%20enclosure-L.jpg) (http://canebas.smugmug.com/Nature/Weather/2015-weather-station-makeover/i-wsL8VNG/A)

As you can see, all the data cables for all the instruments are coming to this box.  If you look carefully, you can see the labels I attached to the wires so I could keep track of which cable went with which instrument.  As indicated at the top, there is a Davis AC adapter plugged into a jack at the top of the transmitter board just above the battery holder.  You can see the ferrite clamp along the right side of the box.

This should have ended any power issues once and for all.  No matter how much current any sensor could need, so long as it was a standard Davis instrument, the station transmitter should have all the power it could ever use.  Since I had bought AC to this location, it was easy to power a fan to improve the accuracy of the temperature/humidity sensor.

This should have solved my problems - right?  *Heavy sigh* . . . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/sad-smiley.png)

Oh well, . . . . . Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on March 22, 2015, 10:18:27 PM
Hey, I recognize one of Herb's batteries in your photo.

This has got to be driving you bonkers. I guess you still have hope that Davis will catch something when they look at that board you sent them. Hang in there.
Title: Afraid so . . . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 22, 2015, 10:43:12 PM
Dear Blick and subscribers to my darn "mellar-drama" . . . .

Hey, I recognize one of Herb's batteries in your photo.

Afraid so, and the darn "bugger" is still discharging.  Yesterday it was down to 3.19 Volts.  Sure it is a very small rate of change, but it shouldn't be happening so long as the transmitter board is plugged into AC.  According to the Davis tech, having the 4.8 Volts of the AC adapter is supposed to change the way the board works so that the battery isn't touched.  That's why I'm not entirely certain that the errors are not related to the way these boards switch between power sources.


This has got to be driving you bonkers. I guess you still have hope that Davis will catch something when they look at that board you sent them. Hang in there.

Roger that, . . . .   I'm wondering if connecting a temperature/humidity probe on a long data cable could possibly damage these transmitter boards somehow.  The board I sent to Davis and the board that is in the station how both "experienced" the long cable run from the temperature/humidity probe.  So if that does some harm to a transmitter board, it would make sense both boards behave in the same way even after I eliminated the "out of tolerance" instrument.

The other transmitter board will arrive at Davis tomorrow and the Davis tech said it usually takes about a week to 10 days to get a board back into my hands.  So hopefully I'll get the repaired board back in 2 weeks or less.

We'll see, . . . . . . .

Stay tuned to this channel (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif) for the latest "breaking" news!  [banghead]

Oh well, . . . . Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 23, 2015, 01:55:42 AM
AhHA! You added the AC adaptor while I wasn't paying attention! ::) I obviously missed that logical plan for trouble-shoting. That's not exactly fair to Herb, however...

OK, being the ignorant newcomer, I have some questions:
1. Is the 'power adaptor' just a small 'wall wart' that plugs into a standard AC receptical? If so, is it warm/hot to the touch?
2. Did you have the 'battery eating' problem before adding the extra temp/humidity sensor?
3. Is it possible to get another cable for that sensor?
4. Can Davis tell us what would happen if any cable had an intermittent short?
5. Are the cable connectors the standard RJ45 type?
Please write your answers on the back of $20 bills and mail to the address I'll PM you. [lol2]
PS: if needed, you can use $10 bills. You're welcome! ::)
Title: Another day, another outage . . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 23, 2015, 08:56:05 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama",

First the news, another day another outage:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20graph%202015-03-23.jpg)

About the same time as yesterday's but a bit earlier.  It still appears that the station transmitter stops transmitting.  We got a bit of rain overnight, but there were no bucket tips during the period of the outage.  So even if no sensor errors are being reported from the rain gauge, it could be simply no data is being transmitted and that isn't counted as a sensor error because no signal is sent unless a bucket tip occurs.  The sensor error pattern is exactly the same if you allow the station transmitter to run out of power and stop transmitting.  I did that test.

Here is the total sensor errors for the past two days:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20live%20data%202015-03-23.jpg)

I did check the battery just in case, but it hasn't moved below 3.19 Volts.

AhHA! You added the AC adaptor while I wasn't paying attention! ::) I obviously missed that logical plan for trouble-shoting. That's not exactly fair to Herb, however...

Actually, I haven't documented the changes I made to the station in the hopes of getting rid of this problem.  I hope to, but I've got a ton of things on my plate right now.


1. Is the 'power adaptor' just a small 'wall wart' that plugs into a standard AC receptical? If so, is it warm/hot to the touch?

The AC adapter is the standard one that will come with your Vantage Pro-2 console.  I just bought an extra one for this job.  I just checked, the transformer end of the adapter is cool to the touch.

2. Did you have the 'battery eating' problem before adding the extra temp/humidity sensor?

The station has had 2 temperature/humidity sensors since it went live in 2009.  The 6382 temperature/humidity station continues to work just fine.  I have replaced the temperature/humidity probe and data cable with a completely new unit after all these problems started in October 2014.  Since Davis recommends against extending the data cable on a temperature/humidity probe, I really had no choice but to buy a new one with the factory data cable.

3. Is it possible to get another cable for that sensor?

Since it is a completely new sensor and cable, that cannot be the problem.

4. Can Davis tell us what would happen if any cable had an intermittent short?

I haven't asked them that question specifically, but I would expect that a problem like that would be unlikely to affect the transmitter only in the early hours of the morning.  That sort of thing should be happening at any time of day.

5. Are the cable connectors the standard RJ45 type?

All the connectors are standard phone connectors.  The temperature/humidity probe uses a standard 6-conductor RJ-12 connector.  The remaining sensors are RJ-11 4-conductor connectors.

Please write your answers on the back of $20 bills and mail to the address I'll PM you. [lol2]
PS: if needed, you can use $10 bills. You're welcome! ::)

 ;) . . . . . Nice try wise-guy!  You - still - haven't paid our consulting fees yet!  If you don't we might be forced to send one of our gorillas to repossess your station! . . . . .  [lol2]

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 23, 2015, 09:50:55 PM
Quote from: answer to #3
that cannot be the problem
Never say "never" (or "cannot").
Quote from: answer to #4
That sort of thing should be happening at any time of day.
Likewise, "should be" are the two most over-used, and connected words in the English language (and I suspect all others)! I always loved "intermittent" problems in the airplane. Maintenance loved them even more. Write up: "Engine 'intermittently' flames out". Maintenance write off:"Intermittently corrected." [lol] Changes in temperature and humidity are often causes for intermittent shorts and other problems. Especially in buried cables. With low voltages, it may simply drain a battery/capacitor or cause signal noise. With high voltages, you can usually smell the burning house!  :o

I think you mentioned examining the circuit board for 'cold solder joints', right?

I'm really not arguing, just saying things we don't think are a problem sometimes are. Just suggesting it is  usually best to sort out problems by starting at the simplest and easiest things to check first. It's even possible that the tiny wire contacts in those RJ cables have got bent away from where they should be. With my eyes, I'd have to use a magnifying glass to confirm they are correctly positioned. 8)

Just trying to come up with things you may not have done; not second guessing things you have done. :)
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 23, 2015, 09:54:48 PM
Quote
You - still - haven't paid our consulting fees yet!
Oops! I just missed the mailman today! I want to hand-deliver the letter to him, to be sure he gets it. OTOH, his truck caught fire a few weeks ago, so that might not be the safest way to get your check to you... I'll go look for my check book, in the mean time... I know it's around here somewhere! [bounce]
Title: A few more details. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 24, 2015, 09:04:00 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and WeatherCat station troubleshooters,

Well, this plot has been going on since last October so there are a few details you haven't been privy to.  One key point that makes straightforward troubleshooting awkward is that these failures have been happening with - 2 - different station transmitter boards.  I bought a new transmitter when all this started and that's the board that I sent back to Davis for repairs.  So the station is using the original station transmitter board that came with the station 5-1/2 years ago.  I'm still getting outages that have all the same symptoms.

I've therefore swapped out the transmitter boards and temperature/humidity probe.  That leaves the remaining instruments as potential suspects: rain gauge, anemometer, and solar radiation sensor.  However, it seems really unlikely that any one of those sensors could be causing problems only late at night but work fine at all other times.  This seems even more unlikely since I spliced the data cables of all three.  If there was a problem with any sensor, extending the distance that the signal travels should have made the situation worse.  WeatherCat reports errors only on the temperature and wind speed only, and has always been consistent in that.  Since the temperature/humidity probe is brand new.  It seems extremely unlikely that brand new piece of equipment would behave like the old one, right down to the interaction with the anemometer.  The behavior really only makes sense if you observe what happens when station transmission stops by removing the battery and unplugging the AC adapter.  In that situation, there is exactly the same pattern of sensor errors.  That seems like a strong case against the other sensors having any problems.  Once more, damaged sensors wouldn't fail on some occasional nights and work perfectly well the rest of the time.

At this point the explanation that seems to best fit the facts is some sort of radio frequency interference.  WeatherCat is reporting sensor errors consistent with no more signal coming from the station transmitter.  There is two ways that could happen.  The transmitter board shuts down, or another radio source overwhelms the station.  However, this doesn't fit the facts very well either.  As noted, there does seem to be a pattern to the outages.  Many occur just after midnight and they are regular in duration.  A machine source for the outages might explain this, but human beings don't have regular schedules in the early morning hours.

The other fly in that explanation is that I've switched my setup to use my console to retransmit the data from the station transmitter.  Now the signal should be good and strong because it only has to travel 20-30 feet on each hop.  Alas, I have observed the outages even in this configuration.  I have also tried switching the transmitter IDs to get out of a range of interference, although I might need to experiment with this some more.

The other strange matter is the issue of 123 batteries discharging when according to Davis they should not be used at all.  As a check on this claim, I checked the voltage of the AA batteries in my Weather Envoy before I put it back into service.  They weren't "fresh out of the box" voltage, but remained at 1.5+ volts after 6 months.  The battery in the station transmitter board has dropped from 3.23 Volts to 3.19 Volts in a month.  That's not a lot of voltage drop by itself, but if that battery is supposed to be completely bypassed . . . . well, something is causing that battery to discharge.  Since that battery is there to deal with potential power disruptions, it is a concern.

So in short there is something really strange going on with station.  I haven't completely torn everything down and examined every component with a fine-toothed comb.  But there is enough information to rule out the vast majority of simple explanations.  Something is just plain weird here.

Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 25, 2015, 01:12:16 AM
Thanks for the update and added info! I won't be offering any more stupid suggestions that you've already done. That's not to say I still won't offer stupid suggestions, of course... [goofy]

Quote
WeatherCat reports errors only on the temperature and wind speed only, and has always been consistent in that.
And those cables were also "spliced"? Exactly how did you "splice" the cable; by crimping on a new male or female connector or by cutting the individual wires?

Quote
Since the temperature/humidity probe is brand new.  It seems extremely unlikely that brand new piece of equipment would behave like the old one
Is it using a new cable? I assume it comes with a short one which is why you needed to "splice" them, assuming you even did that on this particular cable.

Quote
[behavior is duplicated] when station transmission stops by removing the battery and unplugging the AC adapter.
Returning to my first quotation, are you saying that the "temperature and wind speed" are the only sensors that stop transmitting when you remove these two power sources?! Are you saying that solar power is not enough, even with Sunlight, but without the battery and AC? Or are you saying that the Super Cap/Solar power can run all the other sensors except the temp and wind speed?

My simplest suggestion is to change the station/Console ID's and watch/wait. That only requires a dip switch change and probably entering the Console/Envoy settings. But it will rule out the possibility of another station on the same ID. Apparently, the freq is not adjustable, only way to differentiate one transmitter from another is with the 8 different IDs probably assigned to each data packet.

Your station has been in the elements for over 5 years. Mechanical connections can corrode/oxidize with just humidity. That would include the RJ connectors, of course. The battery contacts are relatively easy to clean, the RJ one could be difficult, but it's another possibility you can eliminate with a little elbow grease.

I'm not sure the drain you are seeing is anything more than what you'd see in a battery sitting on a shelf in your house. They all use a chemical reaction to generate electricity and those chemical reactions don't stop just because nothing is connected to the terminals. Unlike humans, batteries are not purfeck! :o

Good luck!
Title: More info. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 25, 2015, 08:39:58 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

First the update.  No errors the past two nights.

Quote
WeatherCat reports errors only on the temperature and wind speed only, and has always been consistent in that.

Precisely.  Every time I've had problems the pattern of errors is the same: external temperature and wind speed errors only.  Oddly, when I have caused the station transmitter to run out of power, the console displays dashes instead of numbers for every sensor.  So the console and Weather Envoy change state in response to the transmitter stopping.  However, apparently Stu cannot get that information out of the computer interface.

And those cables were also "spliced"? Exactly how did you "splice" the cable; by crimping on a new male or female connector or by cutting the individual wires?

Only the anemometer cable has been spliced.  The reason for doing all this was to eliminate the splice on the temperature/humidity probe since Davis no longer recommends extending that cable.  The extensions where done using the Davis 7957 splicing kit:

http://www.davisnet.com/product_documents/weather/manuals/07395-010_IM_07957.pdf (http://www.davisnet.com/product_documents/weather/manuals/07395-010_IM_07957.pdf)

It provides the weather-proof housing shown in the instructions and uses scotchlok connectors to make the splices.  You need to cut the out insulation of the cables (which are 4-conductor telephone wire) but the scotchlok connectors make the actual connections.

Quote
Since the temperature/humidity probe is brand new.  It seems extremely unlikely that brand new piece of equipment would behave like the old one
Is it using a new cable? I assume it comes with a short one which is why you needed to "splice" them, assuming you even did that on this particular cable.

All Davis sensors come with their own data cables.  You should be able spot this now that you have your station up.

Quote
[behavior is duplicated] when station transmission stops by removing the battery and unplugging the AC adapter.
Returning to my first quotation, are you saying that the "temperature and wind speed" are the only sensors that stop transmitting when you remove these two power sources?!

No, all sensors are lost because the transmitter has stopped broadcasting.  You can observe this at the transmitter by turning on a dip-switch that causes an LED to flash every time the station transmits data (about once a second.)  This is useful in troubleshooting.  WeatherCat cannot determine if a sensor has errors unless either the value returned by the data logger is unreasonable (like negative rainfall) or is a sentinel value according to the Davis computer interface.  At least as WeatherCat is presently implemented, it only detects errors from two sensors when the transmitter stops transmitting.

My simplest suggestion is to change the station/Console ID's and watch/wait. That only requires a dip switch change and probably entering the Console/Envoy settings. But it will rule out the possibility of another station on the same ID. Apparently, the freq is not adjustable, only way to differentiate one transmitter from another is with the 8 different IDs probably assigned to each data packet.

I've already tried a number of transmitter IDs without any change in the situation.  Right now the station transmitter is on ID #3 and the console retransmits that data on ID #4.  I have my 6382 temperature/humidity station on ID #2.  Oddly, I've never had a data outage from the 6382 transmitter.  If there was some electromagnetic interference that was blasting across all the Davis station IDs, you would expect I would have sensor errors from both temperature/humidity probes - that doesn't happen.

Your station has been in the elements for over 5 years. Mechanical connections can corrode/oxidize with just humidity. That would include the RJ connectors, of course. The battery contacts are relatively easy to clean, the RJ one could be difficult, but it's another possibility you can eliminate with a little elbow grease.

As you'll learn, the Davis housings are very well made.  The components hold up well if you do a little maintenance.  If you haven't already done it, get yourself some silicone grease for o-rings and lube the o-ring that seals the solar panel door to the transmitter enclosure.  If you do that, it will be easier to open the door to replace the battery and it will make sure the enclosure remains water-tight.

I'm not sure the drain you are seeing is anything more than what you'd see in a battery sitting on a shelf in your house.

Unfortunately, that is clearly not true.  I've been buying these batteries according to Herb's commission at Amazon:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002IGW15G/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1 (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B002IGW15G/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1)

Herb's observation is that Amazon sells these batteries fast enough that they don't end up sitting in inventory and losing power.  If you buy these specialty batteries at your local hardware store, they have have discharged because of slow inventory turn-around for this sort of battery. 

Just after putting the battery in the station I check the voltage under load.  I've gone through something like 24 of these batteries since October and all but one was right on the spot: 3.23 Volts.  The one exception was 3.22 Volts - close enough.  I continue to take voltage readings of the battery while still in the station - thus under any load that the battery might be experiencing.

That is what makes this whole situation - very strange.  The main reason I switched from trying to keep my station solar powered to using an AC adapter is that I was - certain - that would eliminate any power supply problems.  No matter now much power the station transmitter might need, the AC adapter should have been more than up to the task.  So it seems a fool-proof modification to get myself out of this mess.  Davis stubbornly insists that when the AC adapter is connected, the battery is bypassed completely.  If it bypassed, how can the voltage drop?  Okay it will over many months, but I'm seeing changes over weeks.

So as I've said, something is really weird here.  Davis has the newer station transmitter board in their shops right now.  I'm hoping whatever is wrong with it they can fix it and my nightmare will finally be over.

Oh well, Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 25, 2015, 09:45:12 PM
OK. Thanks for the update. Since you now have the original board in the ISS, at least look at the battery contacts with the battery out. It should not hurt to lightly us a rubber (pencil) eraser on them and the battery itself.

The problem you are having is, unfortunately, an intermittent one. I plan on having only permanent types, even if it means the station catches fire! :o

Sorry I can't help.  :'(
Title: Waiting for new transmitter board. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 26, 2015, 09:44:29 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

Another night of no problems.

OK. Thanks for the update. Since you now have the original board in the ISS, at least look at the battery contacts with the battery out. It should not hurt to lightly us a rubber (pencil) eraser on them and the battery itself.

I'll probably leave the current board alone since the newer board that I sent to Davis should come back sometime next week.  When it arrives, I'll swap it back into the enclosure next to the temperature/humidity probe and hopefully that will solve the problem.

I thought I would replace the batteries in both transmitter boards I have and then monitor the voltage drop in both.  Since the second transmitter board is strictly battery powered, that should provide a useful comparison.  If the battery in the board powered by AC drops faster than the battery which is actually powering the other board - I'll know there is something very seriously wrong!

Sorry I can't help.  :'(

Well, I do appreciate that, but you are most definitely not alone.  This problem stumped the much larger WXForum where some serious Davis experts hang out and Davis tech support hasn't been very supportive - to say the least!

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: New board has arrived. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 27, 2015, 10:12:25 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

I got an email this morning that the transmitter board was shipped.  Since Davis is located less than 100 miles from my house, they managed to get the board to me in a day (probably shipped last night.)  Fed Ex ground delivered it this afternoon.  Alas, there is no explanation of what they did to the board, so I can't be sure the problem is fixed.  I might not be able to make the swap until Sunday, tomorrow is looking really busy.  Nonetheless, hopefully I'll be finding out soon enough if my miseries are finally over!

Thanks for your support!!  [tup]

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 27, 2015, 11:07:49 PM
FedEx is great! They also have really nice retirees! Especially the ones who drove their Airbuses! ;) [lol]

P.S.: Don't start with those, "Yeah, but did you hear what they did..." stories! :P
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on March 27, 2015, 11:48:03 PM
Well Edouard, I hope this last swap does the trick.

If not, maybe you could talk some friend into starting his own weather station and letting you use his Vantage Pro in your setup to see if a new one would cure the issue. At least that would narrow it down from (or to) some outside interference.

Fingers crossed for you, buddy!
 [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on March 28, 2015, 02:44:08 AM
Quote
maybe you could talk some friend into starting his own weather station and letting you use his
I'll volunteer Herb's! I'm just a newcomer wanting to help you guys out... 8) :o ;D I'll even see if I can get a FedEx discount for you! (oops. there's no "You're Welcome" smilie! :'( )
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on March 28, 2015, 03:24:10 AM
Let us know Edouard. I know this has been frustrating for you.
Title: Repaired board swapped in. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on March 28, 2015, 11:29:15 PM
Dear xairbusdiver, Herb, Blick, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

I was a terrific struggle but clean living once more prevailed and the board Davis repaired is now doing the station transmitting.  It was a struggle to get the board out of the ISS enclosure I had to put it into so that Davis would be willing to work on it and put it into the 6382 enclosure that the station now uses.  I changed the station transmitter ID from 3 to 7.  The console is now retransmitting on ID 8.  So that should help if there is some radio frequency interference.  But I found the 123 battery all the way down to 3.05 Volts in just 5 days from 3.19 volts.  So there can be no doubt, there some sort of power switching weirdness going on.  I don't know why, but the battery is definitely getting used even when plugged into the AC.

Stay tuned . . . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif)

Edouard
Title: New board isn't enough (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 01, 2015, 12:51:34 AM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Well the hope that the new board from Davis would solve the problem . . . . . has gone down in flames . . . .  [banghead]

Look what I found on my computer this morning:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20graph%202015-03-31.jpg)

Once more a very uniform pattern of errors:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20data%202015-03-31.jpg)

However, there is something interesting.  This time the errors started at 11:48 pm.  This is the first time the errors started before midnight.

That suggested to me that perhaps I have been barking up the wrong tree.

Over the summer, I replaced the Time Machine hard drive and added a second drive to store media away from my MacBook Pro's SSD.  The Weather Envoy was now close to two conventional hard drives.  This problem didn't start immediately after I added the second drive, but EFI phenomena changes by the season and we are having problems with wireless music relay from my computer to the nook stereo.  When I bought my console next to my computer to see if the Weather Envoy was the problem unfortunately, I put it next to the hard drives - I had no other spot to put it.  So It is possible EFI interference from these drives is the culprit.  I was wondering if Time Machine would be running some indexing or pruning old files to make more space around midnight and that would explain when the problem starts and why the problem lasts roughly the same amount of time.

It is a hunch, but I moved the Weather Envoy a good 5-6 feet away from the hard drives on a tall shelf.  We'll see . . . . . .

Stay tuned . . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif)

Cheers, Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 01, 2015, 02:49:07 AM
Well now? that's a horse of a different color! I didn't think about interference coming from your own system, but it could be that you're onto something. I read somewhere that USB 3.0 is very leaky in the 802.11 band. I suppose any communications bus could be leaking, depending on the cable shielding and grounding scheme.

I'm starting to get all positive about the outcome, now. I think you've narrowed it down.

 [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on April 01, 2015, 05:21:50 AM
Waiting for the next update in this saga.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Felix on April 01, 2015, 11:36:08 AM
This would be amazing if it turns out to have been an interference problem all along!
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 01, 2015, 03:48:27 PM
I once used the aluminum foil hat I wear as a temporary shield for some electrical equipment. I didn't leave it off my head for long, however... you can't be too safe!! BTW, do you live near any military bases? They often do thing in the middle of the night, thinking no one else is up! They probably don't know about these 24/7 monitors! They aren't as smart as they want us to think they are. :P Also, be careful what you post here about your findings! They can be nasty when they discover you've discovered their activities!!! I'm new here, but I'd hate to see your post end... prematurely! :o 8) Just remember, even paranoid people have enemies! [roll] [goofy]
Title: Caught in the act! (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 01, 2015, 11:43:10 PM
Dear Blick, Felix, xairbusdriver, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Well, my attempt to relocate the Weather Envoy has definitely indicated something but not what I expected.  At about 11am once more the station "disappeared" from the Weather Envoy.  Alas, I had some errands so I didn't find it until mid-afternoon.  However, once found I could immediately troubleshoot.  The signal was reaching the console, so the problem was clearly in between the console in the nook and the computer room.  It seems that the location I thought was better for reception was probably instead worse.  I relocated the Envoy in the center of the room and once more it was possible to receive the retransmitted signal.

This would be amazing if it turns out to have been an interference problem all along!

I'm certain it cannot just be interference.  Before I moved the transmitter the 123 batteries were clearly getting burned at an outrageous rate.  However, clearly I had multiple problems going on at the same time.  One thing that is very strange is why this all started in the past 6 months.  I'll have to check to see what other devices we might have added at that time which could be the cause.

Progress . . . . perhaps!

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 02, 2015, 12:27:45 AM
Termites?!

If there is a light fixture hanging from the ceiling in the middle of the room (where it helped to put in "middle of the room"), perhaps you could get one of those outlet with a light bulb socket and hang the Envoy ther. At least it wouldn't be a trip hazard sitting in the middle of the floor!! [lol]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 02, 2015, 04:47:16 AM
Make you a foil hat and start shielding one suspect device at a time.   [tup]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 02, 2015, 06:10:44 PM
Apparently, you're not the only one with the problem of mysterious radio frequency emitters.



Are Aliens Behind Mysterious Radio Bursts? Scientists Weigh In (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/04/02/radio-bursts-alien-signals_n_6984870.html?ncid=txtlnkusaolp00000592)

Where's my foil hat? [runoff]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on April 02, 2015, 06:37:07 PM
Now we are on to something!
Title: Suspecting the Envoy (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 02, 2015, 11:22:42 PM
Dear xairbusdriver, Herb, Blick and subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Well there was another outage while we were watching our evening television.  Once more only the Weather Envoy was effected as I could check on the console and the data was still being displayed there.  I had to power-cycle the Envoy before it finally started receiving a signal once more.

There probably are some radio frequency interference issues, but now that I'm retransmitting the signal from the console it really should be strong enough to overcome the interference.  I'm back to suspecting the Envoy.  I'll see what happens over the weekend, but if the outages increase and continue to happen at random times, that suggests a piece of electronic equipment that is dying.

Stay tuned . . . . .  (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif)

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: So much for that theory . . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 03, 2015, 10:52:55 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

Guess what?  I get up this morning and again there are sensor errors according to WeatherCat.  I walk over to the console in the nook and . . . . no data there either!  :o

So the problem isn't simply with the signal from the console to the Weather Envoy.  Rather than jumping on a ladder at 7am, I had my breakfast first and in that time the console and Envoy got a signal once more.

So da' plot has definitely thickened.

Worst still, when I finally got to the transmitter board, the battery is once more discharging.

Since I tried using the higher transmitter IDs and faintly recall having more problems with that I changed tack.  I put the transmitter board on #2, the console retransmit on ID #3, and I moved the temperature/humidity station to #4.

I decided to try some more change.  I removed the AC adapter.  The transmitter board can work fine on the battery alone.  Davis doesn't seem to know much about using these boards on AC adapter.  Perhaps there is something seriously wrong with the circuitry under those conditions and Davis doesn't know it because apparently it essentially has never been used in the field.

Oh well, . . . . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/shrug_shoulders_confused.gif)

Edouard

P.S. There is one more twist to the plot.  This afternoon when I changed the setting on the console it was finding a Davis transmitter at station ID #1.  So there is a neighbor in the area with a Davis station - perhaps a new one that is the reason for my miseries . . . .
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Randall75 on April 03, 2015, 11:47:16 PM
Hi Edouard
 I thinks it is time for a wal;k to see if you can find that new station
Then talk with the owner and see what settings he is using


cheer


 [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 04, 2015, 12:01:49 AM
Another transmitter with the same ID is definitely a problem, unless the two of you want to "combine" your data...

If you want Davis to do something it would be great to at least have a database of station locations that you could have them check for possible conflicts. I'm not sure they'd want to invest the time, money, or security, much less updating, to do that, of course. They don't even have a registration process that I could find (although I would have sworn I saw a link on their site weeks ago! [banghead] ).
Title: No problems after 24. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 04, 2015, 11:21:56 PM
Dear Randall, xairbusdriver, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

First the good news.  Everything has worked perfectly for a day.

I thinks it is time for a wal;k to see if you can find that new station

I have been looking around, but the closest station that I've been able to spot is like 1/8 of mile.  It could be that station but if it is the signal should be extremely weak.

Another transmitter with the same ID is definitely a problem, unless the two of you want to "combine" your data...

It appears to me that there is no station ID conflicts.  The other station appears to be using ID #1 as you would expect virtually everyone do to.  What could be a problem is EFI because there is more noise in that general range of frequencies with a second station around.

We'll see, but I'm back to the hunch the problem is with the AC adapter causing problems somehow.  Time will tell.

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 05, 2015, 01:10:41 AM
⅛ of a mile is well within the range Davis claims. As I understand it, the Envoy is simply a repeater to the Console, therefore, the data logger is in the Console. I also assume the Envoy has a battery as well as the AC adaptor. If that assumption is true, you should be able to take the Envoy to the general area of that other Station and determine exactly what ID it is using. That seems to be the easiest way to narrow down the problems; eliminating things you can control or affect. ;)
Title: Another "midnight" outage . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 05, 2015, 10:34:10 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

Sadly the situation is back to the old pattern.  This morning just after midnight there was a brief outage:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20graph%202015-04-05.jpg)

It only lasted about 5 minutes, but it sure seems connected to some sort of automated activity.  Here is the errors:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20data%202015-04-05.jpg)

I went to check the console diagnostics and it indicates that there was no outage at the station transmitter this time.  Moreover it shows the signal strength to be almost maximum: 58/60.  So at this point it seems much more likely that the problem is in between the console and the Envoy.

⅛ of a mile is well within the range Davis claims. As I understand it.

Well yes, but this station is on the other side of a hill crest from me.  So there is no direct line of transmission.  More importantly, I'm no longer using transmitter ID #1 at all and haven't used it for months.  On the other hand my temperature/humidity station has been at #2 for many years.

The Envoy is simply a repeater to the Console, therefore, the data logger is in the Console.

No you have that reversed.  The console is repeating the signal and the data logger is in the Envoy.

If that assumption is true, you should be able to take the Envoy to the general area of that other Station and determine exactly what ID it is using. That seems to be the easiest way to narrow down the problems; eliminating things you can control or affect. ;)

Again you have that reversed.  There is no control panel on the Envoy.  So you would need to take your Mac along to do anything with it.  Yes, I could take my console in the region of that station, but given that from my house, I could see that it was using ID #1, it seems clear it cannot be an ID conflict.  The problem is most likely radio frequency frequency interference and anything in the same radio frequency range contributes to noise that could result in losing the signal.

However, the symptoms really point to something in my computer setup being the major contributor.  Something has to be generating a lot of RF noise as a result of automated activities after midnight.  The obvious culprits are the hard drives.

I thought I would try to move the Envoy again hoping that perhaps the previous problems were caused by my choosing a station ID that had a greater problem with noise than the lower numbers.  I can also buy a USB extension cable and move the Envoy significantly closer to the console and much father away from the rest of the electronics.  For a $6 investment, it is worth a shot.  If that doesn't work, I think I have to consider replacing the Envoy.  At the moment it appears to be one component that isn't measuring up.

Oh well, . . . . . Edouard
Title: Ordered another Envoy. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 07, 2015, 10:17:29 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Sadly the outages continue.  Yesterday, I once more was lucky enough to have one happen while I was up.  The console was working perfectly but WeatherCat was indicating all channels invalid.  On a whim I decided to power-cycle the Weather Envoy to see what would happen.  Within the usual period needed for a Davis station to pick up a signal, the Envoy once more picked up the signal.  That sure looks to me like a smoking gun that there is some wrong with the Envoy.  If there was interference, power-cycling wouldn't have any effect.

So I bit the bullet and ordered another Envoy from Scaled Instruments.  Alas, there is a typo in the ship to address that I just found.  It is going to:

Orinda, CA
Canada, 94563

How on earth can the post office accept an address like that? . . . . [rolleyes2]

So perhaps my problems will be solved eventually, but like everything else in this struggle - it is stubbornly insisting on doing everything . . . . . da' hard way! [banghead]

*Heavy Sigh*, . . . . . Edouard (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/D'oh.gif)
Title: When things couldn't possibly get worse . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 11, 2015, 12:43:45 AM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

We last left this gripping tale with the Weather Envoy that is the only hope of saving the day plodding its way north to . . . . . Canada. (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/D'oh.gif)

Fortunately, Ryan Wilhour came to the rescue and sent me a second Weather Envoy  . . . . this time to California even!

You can't do better than Scaled Instruments for super service.  [tup]

The very thing was delivered by the postman this afternoon.  In haste I moved my data logger to the new Envoy and put in the batteries.  There was first beep indicating that it had power.  In about 2 seconds there is supposed to be a second beep indicating that it has passed its self-test.  Many seconds passed and . . . . silence.  Concerned about this, I open it up again and confirmed that the data logger was properly seated - it was.  Repeated the experiment.  Alas, once more only one beep was heard.

I went ahead and connected it to my Mac.  I launched WeatherLink and checked to see if it could identify a station - Nope, . . . no station there.

Sadly there was only one thing left to do, try to put the data logger back in the old Weather Envoy and see if I could at least limp along as before.  I reverted my setup into the old Envoy and . . . . everything is now working as before.  So clearly the data logger is still working and the problem has to be with the new Weather Envoy having "issuez." . . . .

I've sent another email to Ryan Wilhour and I'll see what he has to say. but . . . . . . .

When things couldn't possibly get worse . . . . . . oh yes they can!!!  [banghead]

*Heavy Sigh* . . . . . Edouard  :(
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 11, 2015, 01:47:22 AM
I will remind you that I have a very personal acquaintance who put a battery in backwards... can't imagine anyone else ever doing that... still...  [blush] and there are three in that Envoy?!

Perhaps there is some kind of electronic 'worm hole' surrounding your house? Everything that comes through it seems to be inoperative! [banghead]

BTW, I think your comment about Scaled Instruments needs a bit of editing, ie; "...can do..." probably is meant to be "...can't do..." jist sayin'
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 11, 2015, 03:41:01 AM
Edouard, just when I thought you were going to whip this thing by throwing more money at it, it comes back to bit you in the butt like a bad ricochet in a rock quarry!  This meller-drama is turning into a long running soap opera. Only thing missing is the part about who shot JR.

One thing about it, though. After you finish digging yourself into a hole, the only way out is up!

Better luck with the next one, buddy! Watch how you postmark that RMA.

We're pulling for you!

 [cheer] [cheer] [cheer]
Title: Incompatible data logger (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 11, 2015, 10:37:15 PM
Dear Herb, xairbusdriver, and subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

And the cause is . . . . . . . my data logger is too old.  :(

Davis had made firmware changes to the consoles and Envoy that requires data loggers that were manufactured after 2011.  Since I bought mine in 2009 when I bought my station . . . . obviously it is too old.

Ryan at Scaled Instruments thought that Davis would fix a problem like this for free.  But reading their technical bulletin it doesn't read that way to me.  It appears that Davis will upgrade the data logger for free if still under warranty or for their standard service fee if the data logger is out of warranty.  I need to call Davis on Monday to find out.

Oh well, da' darn "mellar-drama" just keeps on going, and going, and going . . . .

Oh well, . . . . Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 11, 2015, 11:17:31 PM
Check that warranty thing for info about customer perseverance... you've shown enough of that to earn a new data logger, not just an upgraded one! [rockon] [cheer]
Title: Has to be a new logger (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 12, 2015, 11:44:26 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

Check that warranty thing for info about customer perseverance... you've shown enough of that to earn a new data logger, not just an upgraded one! [rockon] [cheer]

I got a reply from Ryan Wilhour and he was confident that Davis will give me a new data logger for free.  There isn't any way they can upgrade the old logger.  Apparently there has been a design change.  So I need to call Davis tomorrow and get a RMA number to get the process going.  My station will be down for a few days, but what I can do?

This morning there was another outage, and just as before, power-cycling the Envoy got it going once more.  So that's clearly where the problem is.  Also the weather is as boring and dry as it can be.  If I have to lose some weather data, at least it won't be anything I'll be really sorry to lose.

Oh well, . . . . Edouard
Title: Waiting for new data logger (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 14, 2015, 11:49:14 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Amazingly, I got through to Davis Technical support without even a ring on Monday morning.  I explained my predicament and they agreed to send me a data logger that is compatible with my new Weather Envoy.  I rushed out the old data logger and it has already arrived at Davis.  They said they would ship the new logger in a day or two.  That means it should be shipped today since it wasn't yesterday.  In the meantime I'm stuck without WeatherCat  [WCSmall]  Bummer Dude!  :(

Oh well, . . . . edouard
Title: Re: Waiting for new data logger (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: Blicj11 on April 15, 2015, 03:21:09 AM
In the meantime I'm stuck without WeatherCat

That is the worst!

Davis comping you a data logger is the best.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 15, 2015, 04:24:44 AM
If this does it, you're going to deserve a laurel and hearty handshake!

(http://cdn.splitsider.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Laurel_Hardy.jpg)
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on April 15, 2015, 04:27:34 AM
Ha ha Herb. Good one.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 15, 2015, 04:29:20 AM
I was fixing it.

 [lol2]
Title: Still waitin' . . . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 15, 2015, 09:58:48 PM
Dear Blick, Herb, and WeatherCat impatient types . . . .

UPS, USPS, and the other "usual suspects" in the package delivery business have come and gone and no sign of the data logger still.

The tech guy I spoke with on Monday said they would ship in a day or two.  I suppose in the worst case that would mean it would ship today.  What has me more nervous is that Davis sent me status emails when I sent them in my ISS transmitter board.  I haven't gotten any emails even if they have the old data logger already.

I'll wait until tomorrow morning to see if finally some status emails show up, otherwise it is time to give them another call to find out what gives . . . .

Still waitin'  . . . . Edouard (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/th_smiley-fingertap-gigi.gif)
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 15, 2015, 11:48:52 PM
Just ask them for the tracking number and the shipper; it may be a free exchange, but they should give you that info.

Quote
I haven't gotten any emails even if they have the old data logger already.
Not sure what you mean. I think you said they had received the old logger back in post #69. I thought they said it was an old one and they didn't normally "update" them, anyway. So they probably just put in the circular file. Are you expecting them to notify you of the status of the old logger, other than its arrival?
Title: Data logger finally shipping (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 16, 2015, 10:24:18 PM
Dear xairbusdriver and followers of this darn "mellar-drama"

I called Davis tech support this morning and that appears to have finally gotten things moving.

Just ask them for the tracking number and the shipper; it may be a free exchange, but they should give you that info.

This afternoon I finally got the email I was hoping for.  It is shipping out this afternoon and since they are so close to me it should arrive tomorrow.  Hopefully by this time tomorrow I'll be back on the air!

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 16, 2015, 11:26:34 PM
Good thing Friday the 13th came on Monday this month... ;)
Title: Hurray! On the air once more!! (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 17, 2015, 10:40:14 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama"

Hurray!!  :)  Fed-Ex came through with the new data-logger as promised!  It was actually a complete WeatherLink package . . . . for PC!!  (Anybody want a 4.65"" Frisbee? . . . .  ;D )

Nonetheless, I put the data-logger into the new Weather Envoy.  I then put in the batteries and got the first and second beep!  I went through the configuration walk-through using WeatherLink and then waited . . . . . .

In the usual period of time, the Weather Envoy was picking up the retransmitted signal from the console!   :)

So after being off the air for 5 days hopefully I'm back in business for good!

Thanks for your support!  [tup]

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 18, 2015, 12:20:03 AM
We're all hoping for your success! [tup] Hope it's a great, relaxing weekend for you... finally!
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on April 18, 2015, 01:29:00 AM
We need to hold our collective breaths until tomorrow, when you report back on whether or not you lost connectivity with the Envoy.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 18, 2015, 09:38:20 PM
As the anticipation builds, we find our hero potentially on the cusp of a new era in weather status reporting?

Is it time for a press release yet?

 [sun2]
Title: The broken record continues . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 18, 2015, 10:48:42 PM
Dear xairbusdriver, Blick, Herb, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

And the answer is . . . . . more sensor errors . . . .  [banghead]

Here is the graph:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20graph%202015-04-18.jpg)

and here is the Data view:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outrage%20data%202015-04-18.jpg)

It seems like I have been fighting multiple problems all along.  The old Weather Envoy was quitting at any old time.  The new Envoy seems to be having problems once more just after midnight.  That makes me suspect the hard-drives that I bought last summer.  I hadn't thought this through.  There are 3 computers in this room all of whom have their own dedicated backup hard drive.  I then added a 4th hard drive and put the two drives right next to each other.  I would expect that Time Machine will take advantage of after midnight to do some cleaning.  All these mechanical drives working hard at once, perhaps they do produce enough EMI to interfere with the signal from the console.

I decided to try to put as much space as I could between the Envoy and the hard drives.  I also tried moving them further apart since after all, one is daisy-chained to the other.  Stretching that cable out allowed me to get those drives far enough apart that they won't be generating a single signal from one location.

We'll see if this is enough to reduce the EMI to allow the Envoy to continue receiving even during the Time Machine "witching" hour . . . .

Stay tuned . . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif)  Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on April 18, 2015, 11:41:00 PM
Well, dang it. Let us know.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 19, 2015, 12:06:17 AM
Awwww? So sad.   [banghead]   
Title: Re: The broken record continues . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: Felix on April 19, 2015, 12:33:17 PM
All these mechanical drives working hard at once, perhaps they do produce enough EMI to interfere with the signal from the console.


Couldn't you just skip your backups for a day or two (disconnect and turn off power to the drives) or at least skip the post-midnight run and see if this "mellar-drama" continues through that particular timeframe?

The other thing that comes to mind, it looks from your profile you're using the Cat on a mid-2009 MBP. If you're running Yosemite on it, I think you're one model update away from the oldest laptop upgradable to 10.10. Is there any chance your backups, WeatherCat FTPs and other apps running, coupled with the OS's early-morning housekeeping functions, all happening at once in a post-midnight perfect storm might be bogging down your MBP to the point where this "mellar-drama" just looks and quacks like a duck...but isn't a duck?
Title: For the moment no issues.(Re: Da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 19, 2015, 10:30:43 PM
Dear Blick, Herb, Felix, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

No problems overnight with the new drive arrangement.  I'll just have to watch the situation and see if this indeed finally cures the ills once and for all . . . .

Thanks for your support!!  [tup]

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on April 20, 2015, 01:56:23 AM
Aluminum foil, I tell ya! More aluminum foil!!! Don't forget to completely cover the monitor, either! [rockon] [tup]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on April 20, 2015, 06:25:21 AM
Quote
Aluminum foil, I tell ya! More aluminum foil!!! Don't forget to completely cover the monitor, either! [rockon] [tup]

And save some for the next ham that goes in the oven. Don't want that RFI to interrupt the cooking!

At's right!  [rockon]

 [cheers1]
Title: So far so good . . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on April 20, 2015, 10:05:33 PM
Dear xairbusdriver, Herb, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

So far still everything working fine . . . .

Aluminum foil, I tell ya! More aluminum foil!!! Don't forget to completely cover the monitor, either! [rockon] [tup]

I was so desperate that I even thought of that! (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/eek2.gif)

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: New errors, but perhaps cause identified. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on May 01, 2015, 11:28:27 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Well I was getting close to declaring victory over this problem when . . . . .

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20graph%202015-05-01.jpg)

Still, the outage was shorter than previous ones:

(http://www.canebas.org/misc/Voila_images/Outage%20data%202015-05-01.jpg)

This is also the longest I've gone with out a problem in a long time.  It is almost 2 weeks.  So I'm testing the remaining drive that is older just in case it is dying and is contributing to more EMI than it should.  I'm going to also relocate the remaining drives still further way.  Perhaps radio frequency interfering is truly the remaining obstacle to be overcome.

Thanks for your support!

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on May 02, 2015, 06:29:15 AM
Holy sensor errors Batman! When is this ornery thing going to be identified? Sorry for your frustration.
Title: Thanks, back to okay for now. (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on May 02, 2015, 09:46:55 PM
Dear Blick and WeatherCat  subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Holy sensor errors Batman! When is this ornery thing going to be identified? Sorry for your frustration.

Thanks for your sympathy!

I double-checked one backup drive and it is in good health.  I need to check one more.  I've moved the remaining drives into the same orientation of the first two that seemed suspicious.  No problems overnight.  Just have to wait and see . . . .

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on June 02, 2015, 07:59:21 PM
It's been a while since I've read anything about the major weather disaster in California, and I'm not talking about the water shortage... the last report from Edouard is now a month old! Can we safely assume that his hardware is now operating normally? [cheer] Or, has his problem infected more of the web, even <Apple (http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/06/02/icloud-itunes-again-hit-with-global-outages-impacting-important-services)> specifically?!! :o
Title: I wish . . . (Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on June 02, 2015, 11:30:07 PM
Dear X-Air and WeatherCat  subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

It's been a while since I've read anything about the major weather disaster in California, and I'm not talking about the water shortage... the last report from Edouard is now a month old! Can we safely assume that his hardware is now operating normally? [cheer] Or, has his problem infected more of the web, even <Apple (http://appleinsider.com/articles/15/06/02/icloud-itunes-again-hit-with-global-outages-impacting-important-services)> specifically?!! :o

Alas, no the problem persists although it is less frequent.  I'm certain now this is some sort of radio interference problem.  I've caught it happening in the middle of the day and it is only the link from the console to the Weather Envoy that is failing.  The console never experiences a failure.  The next thing to try is a USB extension cable to see if I could locate the Envoy further away from whatever is the problem.  It might be the case that I have some sort of electronics that is slowly dying when when it finally kicks the bucket my problems will go away.  Something is generating radio frequency interference and there are just to many suspects to easily try to get a handle on the problem.

Oh well, . . . . Edouard (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/shrug_shoulders_confused.gif)
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on June 02, 2015, 11:52:17 PM
Sorry to rub salt into your wounds! [banghead]

Quote
I'm certain now this is some sort of radio interference problem.
Portable wireless house phones? Cross talk with cables around the hardware? I have a pertty good sized 'rats nest' behind my stuff... I think I may just buy some stock in Reynolds Wrap... and don't ever watch NASA TV!
Title: In the queue . . . (Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on June 03, 2015, 09:26:12 PM
Dear X-Air and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Portable wireless house phones? Cross talk with cables around the hardware? I have a pertty good sized 'rats nest' behind my stuff... I think I may just buy some stock in Reynolds Wrap... and don't ever watch NASA TV!

I'll need to explore the matter when I have more time.  At the moment it happens infrequently enough that I can live with it.  As such, I'll continue to focus on the critical path stuff I need to do first.

Cheers, Edouard
Title: Assailant identified in the case!! (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama")
Post by: elagache on December 27, 2015, 09:56:09 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this irregular darn "mellar-drama," . . . . .

There has been perhaps a breakthrough event in this "cold case" . . . . .  (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/detective_emoticon.png)

I have been seeing a slow increase in interruptions between my console and my Weather Envoy.  In a seemingly unrelated event, I discovered that the hard drive that is attached to my Mom's iMac for Time Machine backups wasn't working properly.  I attempted to reformat the drive and . . . .  da' patient didn't recover from the procedure.

It was a very old drive so no big surprise there.  Still, I prefer to have a backup of all computers at all time, so I rummaged around and located another old drive that would pinch hit until a replacement backup drive arrived.  This drive was on standby for my previous MacBook Pro which remains on standby should I have have any need for a portable computer.  Since I was lazy, I simply rerouted the USB connection from my old MacBook to my Mom's iMac which are on the same table and turned on the reserve drive.

After doing this, I had even more trouble with communications failures between my console and my Weather Envoy, having two in 12 hours.  After the second one, I became suspicious.  The reserve hard drive was much closer to the Envoy - coincidence?  I turned the drive off and planned to just run it once a day to back up my Mom's iMac until the new drive arrived.

This afternoon, I turned on the reserve drive and it . . . . didn't mount.  This drive and the backup drive that had failed the day before were the same make,  model, and capacity.  They were most likely bought at the same time.  I assume both drives were close to death and I just pushed them over the edge.

I haven't had any problems with the connection to the Envoy since turning off the drive yesterday.  It is early, but it is a plausible explanation for what was going on.  A dying hard drive might well generate the sort of radio frequency interference that would disrupt the connection between Davis components.

So stay tuned!  (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif)

It appears that an arrest in this case won't be possible, but after all, that will save on legal costs!! . . .  [lol2]

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on December 28, 2015, 02:41:39 PM
Interesting discovery. Let us know if this cures all that ails your patient.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on December 28, 2015, 04:54:42 PM
What was the drive connected to? USB 2.0, Firewire, Firewire 800, USB 3.0, or Thunderbolt?

 [coffee]
Title: So far so good. (Re: "mellar-drama")
Post by: elagache on December 29, 2015, 12:55:04 AM
Dear Blick, Herb, and WeatherCat troubleshooters,

Interesting discovery. Let us know if this cures all that ails your patient.

It is only one day later,  but so far so good!

What was the drive connected to? USB 2.0, Firewire, Firewire 800, USB 3.0, or Thunderbolt?

It was an old Other World Computer drive connected via USB 2.0.  I don't remember how old these drives were, but they had been replaced because they were too small at 250 GB.

Cheers, Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on December 29, 2015, 04:08:02 AM
Yep! I've still got some of those, too. Too small at 250 GB, that is.

 [lol2],
Title: Bummer dude! False lead! (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama")
Post by: elagache on December 29, 2015, 11:22:16 PM
Dear WeatherCat subscribers to this irregular darn "mellar-drama," . . . . .

Bummer dude!  What appeared to be a promising lead turned out to be a dead end.

Even with two suspicious drives dead and waiting for the electronics pickup, I had two new outages in 24 hours.  >:(

That reminded me that using the higher numbered Davis device IDs were more likely to have this sort of problem.  On the other hand, my temperature/humidity station is at ID #4 and never has had problems reaching my Weather Envoy even if it is about the same distance away and getting through about the same number of plaster walls with steel mesh support.

Based on that insight I decided to move all transmitter IDs toward the smaller numbers.  Temperature/Humidity probe is now #1, ISS remains at #2, Console retransmits at #3.   I hope that the difference between a Temperature/Humidity probe and an ISS will resolve any possible conflicts.

Keeping my fingers cross that this time things really work! (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/lucky_shamrock.gif)

Cheers, Edouard
Title: Re: Bummer dude! False lead! (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama")
Post by: Blicj11 on December 30, 2015, 12:50:40 AM
That reminded me that using the higher numbered Davis device IDs were more likely to have this sort of problem.

Interesting. Davis tech support told me to use the higher numbers in trying to sort out my issue in the companion thread. Does anyone have the actual frequencies used by each ID? I can only find the range used by all 8 IDs. I was told that very old wireless telephones can conflict with ID#4.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on December 30, 2015, 07:41:49 PM
The range for all IDs, which you already have, is copied below from the ISS Installation Manual.

902 - 928 MHz FHSS for North America
868.0 -868.6 MHz FHSS for overseas versions: EU, UK, and OV

Old 900 MHz phones are a problem for it in the US, it appears.

The text below is copied from Wireless Vantage Pro2 & Vantage Pro2 Plus Stations.

The ISS and Vantage Pro2 console communicate via an FCC-certified, license-free, spread-spectrum frequency-hopping (FHSS) transmitter and receiver. User-selectable transmitter ID codes allow up to eight stations to coexist in the same geographic area. The frequency hopping spread spectrum technology provides greater communication strength over longer distances and areas of weaker reception.

So my guess: the individual channels are probably mapped digitally onto the same frequency using Davis's proprietary communications protocol.

 [cheers1]
Title: Okay after 24 . . . (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama")
Post by: elagache on December 30, 2015, 10:55:53 PM
Dear Blick, Herb, and WeatherCat Davis troubleshooters, . . . .

Everything is once more working fine, but 24 hours is hardly a test period considering the past experience with this problem.

That reminded me that using the higher numbered Davis device IDs were more likely to have this sort of problem.

Interesting. Davis tech support told me to use the higher numbers in trying to sort out my issue in the companion thread. Does anyone have the actual frequencies used by each ID? I can only find the range used by all 8 IDs. I was told that very old wireless telephones can conflict with ID#4.

Perhaps the problems with your station is different in some way and the Davis advice is correct for your setup.  I've been at this for so long I've forgotten everything I've tried and I didn't start keeping a journal of what I tried until I had gone through a lot of trail and error.

The range for all IDs, which you already have, is copied below from the ISS Installation Manual.

902 - 928 MHz FHSS for North America
868.0 -868.6 MHz FHSS for overseas versions: EU, UK, and OV

Old 900 MHz phones are a problem for it in the US, it appears.

That is what I remembered - Davis was in the 900 Mhz range.  I think our oldest wireless phone is a 900 Mhz unit so that would appear to be a potential culprit.  However, that seems extremely unlikely given the behavior.  Using the phone doesn't seem to cause problems and outages happen when the phone isn't being used at all (like after midnight when everyone is asleep . . . . )

I've been racking my brain pondering if we had another 900 Mhz device in the house but I don't know of anything else.  So the puzzle remains.

Cheers, Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on December 30, 2015, 11:31:07 PM
I don't think I have any 900 MHz devices. If I do, they aren't doing anything at 2:30 in the morning.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Felix on December 30, 2015, 11:39:45 PM
Part 97.303

     A:   902.000 - 904.000   Non-Multilateration
     B:   904.000 - 909.750   Multilateration
     C:   909.750 - 919.750   Non-Multilateration
     D:   919.750 - 921.750   Multilateration and Non-Multilateration
     E:   921.750 - 927.250   Multilateration
     F:   927.250 - 927.500   Narrow band associated with sub-band E
     G:   927.500 - 927.750   Narrow band associated with sub-band D
     H:   927.750 - 928.000   Narrow band associated with sub-band B
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on December 30, 2015, 11:42:21 PM
Felix, you are the man! Thanks.
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on December 31, 2015, 05:15:57 PM
I don't get it. What does it all mean?

Quote
Part 97.303

     A:   902.000 - 904.000   Non-Multilateration
     B:   904.000 - 909.750   Multilateration
     C:   909.750 - 919.750   Non-Multilateration
     D:   919.750 - 921.750   Multilateration and Non-Multilateration
     E:   921.750 - 927.250   Multilateration
     F:   927.250 - 927.500   Narrow band associated with sub-band E
     G:   927.500 - 927.750   Narrow band associated with sub-band D
     H:   927.750 - 928.000   Narrow band associated with sub-band B
Title: Davis interfering with itself? . . . (Re: da' darn "mellar-drama")
Post by: elagache on December 31, 2015, 11:46:33 PM
Dear Blick, Felix, Herb, and WeatherCat Davis troubleshooters,

Last night just before I was about to retire for the usual dose of Boob Tube . . . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif)  My darn Weather Envoy lost its connection once more.  However, this time I caught it almost immediately after it started.

Using my new trick, I switched the ID to something other than the retransmission ID I'm using and put it immediately back.  Within a minute, the communications was working once more.

That seems to rule out an outside source of interference.  If it was something external, it stopped almost as fast as it started since I caught almost as soon as it started.  That make me think about what Herb said with respect to the Davis IDs:

So my guess: the individual channels are probably mapped digitally onto the same frequency using Davis's proprietary communications protocol.

Because I had so much trouble in the past, I had done something that perhaps was the cause of my problems rather than a solution.  I broadcast from the ISS on ID #2.  Then I rebroadcast that information from the console to the Weather Envoy on #3.  In principle, there should be no need for this rebroadcasting, the ISS is close enough to the Envoy so that I should be able to pick up the signal directly without the "boost."

At the time, I didn't see any harm because by rebroadcasting I thought I was only making sure the signal was good and strong.  However, Davis may not expect to have the original signal (on #2) and the rebroadcast signal (on #3) arriving at a receiver at comparable strength.  Normally, Davis data is always different, and their technique to determine signal and reject noise may rely on that.  If the signal on #2 and #3 are the same, could this cause the Envoy to effectively "become confused?"

It is easy enough to check this hypothesis out.  I turned off retransmiting on the console and I am using ID #2 only, so that both the console and the Envoy get their data directly from the ISS alone - no potential interference.

So far so good . . . .

Stay tuned . . . . (http://www.canebas.org/WeatherCat/Forum_support_documents/Custom_emoticons/tune_in_TV_emoticon.gif)

Cheers, Edouard  [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Felix on January 01, 2016, 11:06:21 AM
So-ooo, it's sure starting to sound like an interference (vs. hardware) problem all along as many of our armchair sleuths have believed. I'd never questioned why you were boosting the signal since I'm not familiar with your layout and the distances involved. This seems to be the most logical explanation I've heard thus far.

And Herb...

Blick had asked what frequencies the eight Davis station IDs corresponded to. The FCC breaks up the 33-centimeter (900 MHz) band into eight discrete freq ranges which are used for everything from cordless phones to garage door openers to TV remote controls to amateur radio controllers to you name it.

And it appears that Davis likely uses all eight freq ranges. You can see why Blick was told by Davis techs to use the higher numbered IDs when troubleshooting (narrower range...but less forgiving if there is oscillator drift).
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Blicj11 on January 01, 2016, 07:07:26 PM
Interesting development. I'm not using an Envoy, just transmitting wirelessly to the VP2 console, but I see the same results when it looses the connection. When I change the ID on the console and then change it back, it immediately connects and resumes.
Title: Okay after 24 . . .(Re: Darn "mellar-drama" continues!!)
Post by: elagache on January 01, 2016, 11:06:54 PM
Dear Felix, Blick, and WeatherCat subscribers to this darn "mellar-drama,"

Well once more not enough time to tell, but so far so good . . . .

Cheers, Edouard
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: Bull Winkus on January 02, 2016, 05:19:09 PM
Thanks Felix! ? So, those are the FCC's bands; not Davis's channels? Is there some correlation? I would expect that spread-spectrum frequency-hopping (FHSS) would be all over the place under digital control.

Also, Multilateration has to do with navigation and geo-location, so I would expect Davis to be restricted to channels for Non-Multilateration. That's only A, C and D, unless the rules for FHSS is different. [Edit: Just noticed that all of the band is shown as Government only. FHSS must be different.]

Quote
Part 97.303

     A:   902.000 - 904.000   Non-Multilateration
     B:   904.000 - 909.750   Multilateration
     C:   909.750 - 919.750   Non-Multilateration
     D:   919.750 - 921.750   Multilateration and Non-Multilateration
     E:   921.750 - 927.250   Multilateration
     F:   927.250 - 927.500   Narrow band associated with sub-band E
     G:   927.500 - 927.750   Narrow band associated with sub-band D
     H:   927.750 - 928.000   Narrow band associated with sub-band B

[Added] Link to Wiki article on FHSS. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequency-hopping_spread_spectrum)

Link to full image below. (https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/d/df/United_States_Frequency_Allocations_Chart_2011_-_The_Radio_Spectrum.pdf)

Also, ISM Band Wiki link. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISM_band)

 [cheers1]
Title: Re: *Sniff* . . da' darn "mellar-drama" continues!!
Post by: xairbusdriver on January 02, 2016, 07:49:10 PM
We had/have serious concerns at church where a lot of wireless mics are used (lots of professional performers use them, also). Unfortunately, wireless mic users are a niche group compared to cell phone service, so there's little security for purchasers of these kinds of microphones. Even adding Davis to the group (even though they are using different freqs) wouldn't add any real power compared to AT&T/Verizon/et al. :(